Having been away from home for almost two and a half years, I've been missing some of the things that I took for granted back in Malaysia, one being cha siu bao (叉燒包) or Hong Kong-style steamed buns with Cantonese barbequed pork filling.
In Chinese Cantonese and Mandarin, a filled steamed bun is called "bao." They can easily be found in any Chinese restaurants that serve Hong Kong-style dimsum (港式點心). Now, why I said it's Hong Kong-style? That's because after mingling with some Chinese from mainland China, I realized that 點心 means sweet pastries to them. Haha! So, you see though we're all Chinese, there're still some slight cultural differences among us ... when you compare the Northerners to the Southerners especially!
I believe the last time I had cha siu bao was in late 2006 before I left home. My fifth aunt would get us some cha siu bao from a famous dimsum restaurant nearby her house in Kepong (somewhere in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.) Both my younger brothers love them especially because they were the ones who would wipe these buns off!Lately, I felt motivated to venture into making homemade cha siu (Cantonese barbequed pork) and Chinese steamed buns. I think this sudden urge rose due to my craving for these buns, my discovery of a pack of pork in the freezer, and the fact that I'd been wanting to try my hands on steaming buns. And better yet, my recent discovery of a GREAT bao recipe on MH's blog! It seemed that the stars were aligned for some bao making!
Aside from my terrible pleating skills, I realized that making good baos isn't that difficult. (Learn more about pleating here .) Other than having a good recipe, some understanding of the ingredients' functions definitely helps. I'd heard from some mainland Chinese telling me that, "弄饅頭需要什么配方啊!!" ("Making mantou doesn't need recipes!!") But at the same time when you're so particular about the result, I do think a formula is necessary! I just hate when some people complain about the food, and yet, refuse to understand the ingredients and follow a recipe precisely. After all, it's all about science!
The recipe from MH's blog yields soft and fluffy steamed buns. They're mainly leavened by baking powder even though a small quantity of yeast is called for. I do believe the yeast is there to provide texture and taste. In fact, we have to make a 12-hour starter dough for this recipe. It's sort of like a shortcut version of the laomian (老麵) method, which is an equivalent to Western sourdough starter--minus the sourness.
I believe that it's the laomian that keeps the buns moist and soft for a fairly long period of time. Actually, I proved the laomian for about 14-1/2 hours because I slept in that morning LOL! Luckily, it didn't turn sour. But as I proceeded with the remaining steps, I found myself having to add more water and some oil to the dough as it was fairly dry. Could this be due to the type of flour that I used and the weather? Very likely ...
Normally, a special type of flour called Hong Kong bao flour is used to make steamed buns. It's bleached and very low in gluten; hence, the white-colored baos seen at restaurants. Mine became yellowish because I substituted bao flour with mostly cake flour--the closest alternative that I could find. Nonetheless, what I was after was the buns' texture. And, I got it!
I read from Jodeli's forum that low-gluten flours make way for baos to smile during steaming. So, forget about those recipes that call for bread or all-purpose flour if you're looking for smiling baos. In the meantime, baking ammonia is traditionally used for making baos served at dimsum restaurants. Though I haven't experienced it myself, I heard that it stinks real bad! No wonder it's called 臭粉 in Chinese, which literally means "stinky powder!"With the bad things I've heard about and the fact that I don't have it, I decided to use baking soda in place of baking ammonium. Why? This is something I learned when I made my first apom balik, a.k.a. min jiang kuih. I reasoned that baking ammonia becomes alkaline when dissolved in water; therefore, its role as a leavener will only happen in the presence of an acid. In the recipe below it calls for 1/2 tsp of vinegar. Ah-ha! All these started to make sense to me. (Well, baking soda and powder aren't good for us, too, I know ...)
With all the modifications, the baos still smiled at me like nobody's business LOL! I was so happy except I do think the smiling baos somewhat look like fatt koh (Chinese sweet steamed rice cake!) As for the cha siu filling, I sort of did it by referring to recipes and methods from several sources. So, it was mostly eyeballing. I'll document it better the next time I make cha siu again. Anyhow, I better stop rambling and make way for the recipe!
Hong Kong-Style Steamed Buns (adapted from MH's)
Makes thirty 30g buns
Starter dough:
(A)
110g warm water, at 43C/110F
1/8 tsp active dry yeast
(B)
185g Hong Kong bao flour (I used cake flour)
1/2 tsp double-acting baking powder
Main dough:
(C)
375g Hong Kong bao flour (I used cake flour)
200g sugar
*the baos were sweet, adjust the quantity if you'd like them less sweet ... but not too much!)
20g double-acting baking powder
5g baking ammonia *I used baking soda of the same amount
23g shortening
75g water
1/2 tsp vinegar (I used apple cider vinegar)
- Dissolve together (A) and let sit aside till mixture turns frothy
- Combine together (B), then mix in yeast mixture to combine; leave to prove for 12 hours in a covered container under room temperature *I proved mine for about 14-1/2 hours and it was alright.
*Alternatively, mix all the ingredients for the starter dough together if you're using instant yeast - After 12 hours of proving, the starter dough should feel soft and moist. Mix in (C) to the starter dough to combine well; continue to knead till you get a not-quite-sticky dough ball
- Divide the dough by 30g and shape each into a ball
*I divided mine by 40g as recommended by MH. Worked for me anyway - Roll each smaller ball of dough out with the center slightly thicker than the edges
- Place some filling in the center of each circle of dough, then pleat and seal to enclose the buns
- Steam the filled buns immediately over high heat above rolling-boiling water for about 10-12 minutes
*Be fast; otherwise, the baking powder will lose its potency - Serve baos hot or warm
21 comments:
Hi!
Just discovered your blog! :)
When I first saw your bao in flickr, I thought it was a "huat kuih"! :D
Good job! your baos look very pretty and nice!
BTW, I don't think cake flour will yield such "brownish" skin... (way too brown to me, initially I thought you substitute white sugar to brown sugar). I'd used cake flour to make other type of baos too, the bao skin was white (but not as white as the smiling bao). Could be the bicarbonate soda & apple cider vinegar you use? (just my thought only, don't get offended!)
Once again, congrats on your new blog and hope to see more posts and great photos from you! :)
Thanks a lot MH for dropping by!!
Me, too! I think they resemble fatt koh LOL! I'm also unsure of the apple cider vinegar and bicarbonate soda issue ... My mom actually suspected that the "overbrowning" of the bao skin could be a result of resteaming, especially when the buns have been resteamed for several times. The more they're steamed, the browner they'll get!!
Once again, thanks for dropping by! Hehe! I also follow your blog--but as a silent reader though ...
Hi,
I saw your 17-hour bread in Flickr, can you pls share your recipe?
Oh yes! I'll eventually ... The problem with me is that I churn out things faster in the kitchen and slower in front of the computer LOL! I also have the tendency to be conquered by my lazy bones hahaha ...!
Halo, may i ask what is shortening in your recepi because i am newbie cook^^
Shortening is a form of saturated, oftentimes, vegetable oil ... But, it's not margarine! You can look for any brand of shortening to use. Still, if you don't get what I mean. Just go for the brand Crisco. Shortening is white in color. If you do know Chinese, it's called 固體菜油 or 白油.
Hope these help! Please let me know if you'd like to know anything else. Cheers! Happy cooking and baking!
P.S. Don't say that you're a newbie! Everyone is because we're learning everyday! =)
Thx for your explaination^^ because now i dun hv a oven so i think i will on some recepi that use the stim technique
Happy cooking to you then! Do let me know how it turns out yea? =)
Pei lin, wan ask if wan buy oven 18 inch enough to bake any cake and others ?
I guess it's possible provided that what you're looking for are small cakes, bread loaves and buns, cookies (biscuits), tarts, quiches and so forth.
Hope you're having fun with cooking and baking!! Once again, thanks for dropping by!
wan ask more , normally we can use the hand beater egg utensil to beat until cream or not by not using the beater machine?
Oops!! Sorry, Eric!! I just realized there is a question here that's not been answered yet!! So sorry!
I'm sure you can do without the hand mixer like our forefathers, but it's going to take you quite a while till you get to the creamy, pale & fluffy stage!
Hope this helps!! Let me know should you have any other questions!
Pei-Lin
Hello! i just found out about your blog cause you have such creative titles! Well because i study food chemistry, so actually steaming will not producing browning despite many times of resteaming. This is because sugar will only brown, (either by caramelization/maillard reaction) when temperature reaches 170 degrees celsius and maximum temperature for steaming is only 100 degrees. It is insufficient for any browning reaction to take place.
Hi Pei Lin,
I made your char siew bao as I promised I would. Unfortunately, it was a disaster!! It EXPLODED!!. I know. I later found out that the HK flour that I have has already got D/A Baking powder in it. No wonder I thought the sponge was reacting too much when I made it. Also, the dough became very sticky and I had to add more flour. When I steamed, it exploded inside. I wasnt sure if I should laugh or cry. Anyways, the story doesnt end too badly. Since I still have lots of char siew filling and no more HK flour, I proceeded to make the pau dough using the yeast method following a recipe by rasa malaysia. It worked and all was not lost at the end. The pau was soft and fluffy and everyone was happy at the end with a full stomach :)
OM
Hi Pei-Lin,
THANKS for posting your beautiful bao.I have tried so many recipes and failed in them at lot. I live in California and we don't have HK flour, the next best thing I found is the "Queen Guenevieve Bleached Cake flour, by King Arthur Flour". the result was much better than using regular "cake flour".
Also there is "primaflour.com" site where you can check their recipe, it's longer but it seems to be a good one.
Ah! Once I didn't have "baker's Amonia" and used baking soda instead my baos came out like the colors you got.
The smell goes away as you steamed the baos.
Regards
Pauline H. :)
Hi, Pauline! Thank you for dropping by and to say hi, too. I appreciate it.
I suppose any bleached cake flour would work well, if there is no access to HK bao flour. But I still like this recipe a lot, I'm happy with it so far. Seriously, yours turned out to have a similar hue like mine when baking soda is used in place of baking ammonia? I suppose the smell of the baking soda goes away during the steaming process. Thank you for reaffirming my observation here. Thank you for sharing your experience with me. =)
Have a lovely week ahead!
With regards,
Pei-Lin
Hey Pei Lin,
Thanks for commenting on my post!!
I tried your recipe and love the taste of the baos but since we don't have HK Flour here in California they did notopen like yours... :(
I really think that the flour is the key ingredient for a smilling end result because I have tried TONS of recipes and none of them gave me a smiling bao.
I know that there is a
great "secret" that the dim sum's chefs and cookbooks don't tell...
In the mean time I'll continue my experiments.
For those that would like to find "baker's amonia" here in the USA, "King Arthur Flour" website has it and it's around US$7.
My Best Regards
Pauline :)
Hey, Pauline! Thank you so much for the detailed feedback! Really appreciate it. =)
No, no. The baos were made when I was still in Minnesota. I couldn't find HK bao flour there, either, and I substituted it with cake flour. Just be sure the flour used has very low gluten content.
Another important thing to take note of with these baos is the kneading process. Don't overknead, and thus overdeveloping the gluten. Haha! You know, I hardly buy cookbooks published in Asia. There are just too many things about them I can't stand, including their stinginess in sharing information. *Sigh*
It's been very kind of you to generously share your findings with us here. May all the best come your way. In the meantime, happy cooking! =)
Enjoy the weekend.
With warmest regards,
Pei-Lin
Hi Pei Lin,
So GLAD to know you did the baos here in the USA. Which brand of cake flour did you use? Softsilk? I know the Queen Guenevire by King Arthur Flour company has the lowest amount os gluten and they say it's the whitest.
THANKS for the biggest tip, I do believe I over knead the dough....
I'll handle the dough less next time.
Also during my searches, I came across with the Vietnamese rice cakes made with rice flour or the
"fatt koh" from the cantonese.
I have made those and they smile like crazy!!! so maybe rice flour is something for me to think about...and they are so white in color!! I also heard some people saying that there is rice flour is the cha sao bao dough...
I agree with you when it comes to chinese stinginess.... I bet it's something really simple and they must keep it as a secret or else.
I have friends who owns chinese restaurants and asked about the dough and they say: "don't eat too many, there are too many quimicals in the dough"....
Yet, no recipe.
One of these days I'll get it right and in the mean time, will try your recipe again without kneadding too much :)
BEST REGARDS
THANKS AGAIN
Pauline Hsu:)
Dear Pei-Lin,
WOW!!! I think I was doing all wrong!!! THANKS for the great tip!!!I was kneading too much!!!
Also, which cake flour brand did you use when you made the baos here in US? "Queen Guenevere" from King Arthur Flour is the one I used, only problem US$8 for 3lb bag. Too expensive, I don't believe the rests. will use that brand.
Some people also mentioned using some rice flour in the dough... like the "fat koh". Once I made fat koh using rice flour and each one of them smiled like crazy!!! I also noticed they are so much alike!!
My friends' friend own a rest. and even they can't get the recipe from the chefs, the owner said:"there are too many quimicals in it, don't eat too many".
Talking about chinese chefs' stingeness !!!
Ah! another question, did you use bamboo steamer or metal pan steamer? I know that to make fat koh, the recipe calls for pre-heating the cups in the steamer and then filling with the batter and steam. It seems that high heat from the beginning give the fat koh a good head start!!
Ah! Like you I'm also from the East meets West culture. I was born in HK, moved to Brazil when I was 2, came to US at 21 and been living here ever since. Home for me is Brazil, where my family still lives.
Love your way of life and your website is really inspiring!!!
I'll try your recipe again and I'll let you know the results.
Warm Regards
Pauline H. :)
Hey, Pauline!
Very sweet of you to leave me such encouraging words. I'm sorry for not getting back to you promptly, been busy over here. And thank you so much for sharing a little bit about yourself. I really appreciate that!
I've not used King Arthur's flours thus far, not even when I was in Minnesota. I used cake flour imported from Taiwan, which was bought from an Asian grocer in the Twin Cities (Minneapolis-St. Paul area). I can't recall the brand, though, so I'm sorry about that. It's been almost two years. Haha! I'm getting old, apparently.
The steamers I had back in the States were made of metal, and thus, they were already getting "preheated" while the water inside the steamers was brought to the boil. Seriously, what I think that matters the most has to be the kneading process and leavening agent(s) used in the dough. As for the rice flour, I've heard of that, but have yet to try that myself. AND, I've not made fatt gou (simply because I'm never a fan of fatt gou).
Okay. I shall wait for your results here in the meantime. Take care. Have a good weekend ahead! Thank you so much for being supportive!
Now, bedtime for me -- it's approaching 1.30 am. here. Tired and sleepy.
With warmest regards,
Pei-Lin
Post a Comment